Is Your Toilet Handle Loose? 

Last Updated On September 29, 2022
toilet handle loose

Is your toilet handle loose? We’ve been there. 

It’s only when our toilet doesn’t work that we realize we take flushing our waste for granted. We do our business, close the lid and push the handle down. 

Not everything, however, always goes as planned. What happens if the handle just flops in place? 

Without resistance behind the toilet handle, we can assume nothing is working inside the tank. While this might take replacing the flushing assembly, what can we do to get this flushed away now? 

We aren’t always at home when we run into a loose toilet handle. The last thing we want is to leave a surprise for the next visitor. 

Let’s talk about how you can fix that loose handle!

What's In This Guide?

      Loose Toilet Handle: What To Know

      A loose toilet handle is usually an easy fix. It is also a common problem. We can figure out the problem by paying attention to how the flush lever functions. 

      First and foremost, we check the nut holding the handle into place. This nut must be tight. It’s also important to know that it has reverse threads. 

      The flapper chain is disconnected if nothing happens when we jiggle the tank lever. 

      If the handle can slide in and out a bit from its designated hole on the tank, the nut that secures it into place might be coming loose. 

      There is no need to call a plumber. A loose toilet handle is nothing to worry about and can usually be fixed in minutes. 

      Below are the four most common situations we run into with a loose toilet handle.

      Situation 1: Toilet Handle Is Loose And Won’t Flush

      A reverse threaded nut secures the toilet handle into place when we push it down to flush. The nut needs to be tight for the tank lever to pull up the chain to the flapper. 

      The chain connects to the other side of the handle, and pulls up on the flapper, releasing the water into the toilet bowl. 

      This chain must be the exact length necessary for that specific toilet. If the chain is too long or disconnects from either location, the toilet handle will wiggle freely without allowing any water to leave the tank.

      Situation 2: Toilet Handle Loose, But The Nut Is Tight

      If we notice our toilet handle is loose, we should first look at the nut holding the handle into place. This nut could be metal, brass, or in most cases, plastic. 

      The handle has a threaded shaft that slides into its designated hole on the toilet tank. With the handle in its correct position, this nut should be butted up tightly to the back of the tank. 

      It might be loose and feel completely tight if the nut breaks or the threads get stripped. If this is the case, we will need to replace the toilet handle assembly.

      Situation 3: Toilet Handle Nut Keeps Coming Loose

      Finding stripped threads on our toilet handle isn’t that uncommon. Some of the handles that are available to purchase are weak plastic or soft brass. 

      In any case, this will cause the toilet handle nut to keep coming loose. Because this is such an easy fix, and the parts are inexpensive, we recommend installing a new handle. 

      Your new handle will come with a new nut as well. Sometimes the damaged threads can be hard to spot. We recommend changing both the handle and the nut, simultaneously. 

      It might be a good time to upgrade your flushing handle. 

      For all the latest styles and trends, Amazon has all the latest toilet handle replacement styles, and always at unbeatable prices. 

      Situation 4: Toilet Handle Loose Water Running

      “Just jiggle the handle!” We’ve all either heard that before or said it before. 

      If you notice that your toilet handle is loose, but the water is constantly running, this might signal two problems. 

      First, the chain that connects to the flapper could be too short. When we push down on one side of the tank lever, the chain connecting to the flapper pulls upwards. 

      When the flapper lifts, it uncovers the drain hole leading to the toilet bowl. The fresh water is gravity-fed down into the bowl. 

      With the chain being too short, the flapper can’t sit completely flush against the flapper valve. 

      A small crack or hole in the seal could cause our running toilet. If the flapper is set perfectly in place and the chain looks good, the flapper might be dirty or worn. 

      Our toilet flapper is made of rubber and will eventually wear out. We can purchase an entire flush valve assembly and fix this problem ourselves.

      Did you know? The nut holding our toilet’s flushing lever in place has reversed threads. It is not uncommon to strip these out from turning the nut in the wrong direction.

      did you know loose toilet handle

      How To Fix A Loose Toilet Handle In 5 Easy Steps

      No matter how bad our flush handle catastrophe may seem, we can help you avoid an expensive plumbing service call. 

      While many things could be responsible for a broken toilet handle, we can show you how to fix a loose toilet handle in five steps. 

      1. Step one is to shut down the water supply to the toilet we are working on. If we can’t find the individual shut-off for that specific toilet, we have to shut the water down to the entire building or home. 

      2. Step two is to remove the lid from the tank. It is a bit heavy and made of porcelain so use extreme caution when setting this out of the way. 

      3. For step three we need to perform is disconnecting the chain from the handle that leads down to the flapper at the bottom of the toilet tank. 

      With the chain disconnected and the back of the handle accessible, we can move on to step four, loosening the nut that holds the handle in place. This nut has reverse threads and will strip if overtightened. 

      4. Now that we have our tank lever off, we can slide in the new one and tighten the new nut. This is step four. We can’t forget to reconnect the chain that lifts the toilet flapper. 

      5. Now it’s on to step five, returning the water supply to the toilet. 

      With the lid still removed, we can watch the flushing assembly at work. When everything works perfectly, we are good to set the top back onto the toilet tank.

      Here is a video to help fix a loose toilet handle. 

      What Is The Best Toilet Handle For Replacement?

      Most toilet handles on the market today are universal and can be adjusted to fit in any tank.

      Some flushing handles match specific brands of toilets. We recommend checking the manufacturer for the exact size you need. 

      From American Standard’s basic replacement handle to Korky’s selection of stylish and modern replacement flushers, Amazon offers every type of flush handle we want or need. 

      When we have a loose toilet handle, we can fix it ourselves. Amazon is sure to have the perfect replacement for any toilet. We will guide you in the replacement process every step of the way.

      FAQs: Loose Toilet Handles

      What does it mean when the toilet handle is loose?

      We can usually fix a loose toilet handle by tightening the nut inside of the tank. We can also check the chain that connects to the toilet’s flapper. It gets disconnected sometimes.

      Why is my toilet handle loose and not flushing?

      Our toilet’s flushing handle is responsible for the entire flushing process. Without a secure lever, nothing on the flushing assembly will work correctly.

      What is the best universal toilet handle for replacement?

      Amazon has a giant selection of Kholer, universal handles in every style. You’re guaranteed to find the perfect one for your toilet at a price you can afford.

      Meet Your Plumbing Navigator

      Plumbing Navigator: plumbing advice

      About Plumbing Navigator

      We’re passionate about all things plumbing, and love sharing tips, “how-to”, and reviewing the latest products to help make your project a success!

      Learn More Plumbing Tips

      Want to tackle more plumbing projects? Check out these helpful guides!

      How to Run Plumbing to a Detached Garage
      What is a Leach vs Drain Field
      How Long Does a Septic Leach Field Last
      How Does a Septic Leach Field Work

      Got Plumbing Questions? Search For In-Depth Answers Below!

      About Plumbing Navigator

      We write about "all things plumbing," helping you navigate common questions, repairs, and the best plumbing products on the market.

      About Plumbing Navigator

      We write about “all things plumbing,” helping you navigate common questions, repairs, and the best plumbing products on the market.

      Recently Published Guides